Amazon Echo vs Apple HomePod: Yikuphi Owudingayo?

Kuningi lokukhetha lezi zinsuku kuzikhulumi ezihlakaniphile . I- Amazon Echo cishe iyaziwa kakhulu, kuyilapho i- Apple HomePod ekhishwe yi-2018 ingumdlali omncane.

Zombili amadivaysi angenza izinhlobo ezifanayo zezinto-ukudlala umculo, ukulawula amadivaysi smart home, ukuphendula imiyalo yezwi, uthumele imiyalezo-kodwa abawenzi ngendlela efanayo noma ngokulinganayo kahle. Uma uqhathanisa i-Amazon Echo ne-Apple HomePod, ukucabanga ukuthi iyiphi idivayisi engcono kuwe kuncike ezintweni eziningi, kufaka phakathi izici ezibaluleke kakhulu kuwe nakwamanye amadivaysi namasevisi ofuna ukuyisebenzisa.

Umsizi ohlakaniphile: Echo

Isikweletu somfanekiso: PASIEKA / Science Photo Library / Getty Images

Into eyenza i-"smart" isikhulumi sehlakaniphile ngumsizi osebenze ngezwi owakhiwe kuwo. I-HomePod, yi- Siri . Nge-Echo, i- Alexa . Ukuthola okuningi kulawa mathuluzi, uzodinga owodwa ongenza okungcono kakhulu. Yilokho i-Alexa. Ngesikhathi uSiri enhle (futhi ehlangene ngokujulile ku-Apple ecosystem, njengoba kuxoxwe kamuva), i-Alexa ingcono. I-Alexa ingenza izinto eziningi, ngenxa "yamakhono" adalwe ngabathuthukisi benkampani yangaphandle. I-HomePod isekela amakhono ambalwa kuphela wesithathu. Ngaphandle kwalokho, ukuhlolwa kutholile ukuthi i-Alexa inembile kakhulu ekuphenduleni imibuzo nasekuphenduleni imiyalo kuneSiri.

Ukusakaza Umculo: Ukuzibopha

Isikweletu somfanekiso: Apple Inc.

Kokubili i-Echo ne-HomePod isekela ngetani lezinsizakalo zokusakaza, ngakho-ke isiphi isikhulumi osithandayo cishe sincike kumhlinzeki wakho womculo ozithandayo. I-Echo inikeza ukwesekwa komdabu kuwo wonke amagama amakhulu- Spotify , Pandora, njll-ngaphandle kwe- Apple Music . Nokho, ungakwazi ukudlala i-Apple Music ku-Echo phezu kwe-Bluetooth. I-HomePod, ngakolunye uhlangothi, isekela kuphela i-Apple Music, kodwa ikuvumela ukuthi udlale wonke amanye amasevisi usebenzisa i-AirPlay . Uma ungumsebenzisi we-Apple Music osindayo, i-HomePod izoletha isipiliyoni esingcono-ngoba isekela imiyalo yezwi le-Siri futhi ihambisa umsindo ongcono (ngaphezulu kwalokho) kodwa abalandeli be-Spotify bangase bakhethe i-Echo.

Ikhwalithi Yomsindo: I-HomePod

Isikweletu somfanekiso: Apple Inc.

Ngaphandle kokungabaza, i-HomePod yiyona isikhulumi esihlakaniphile esihle kakhulu emakethe. Akumangalisi ukuthi: Apple igxile kakhulu ngokuletha ikhwalithi enkulu yomsindo futhi yakhelwe i-HomePod ukuze isebenze ngokuyinhloko njengezinsiza zomculo (empeleni, kubonakala sengathi igcizelele umsindo phezu kwezici "ezihlakaniphile"). Uma ikhwalithi yomsindo ibaluleke kakhulu kuwe, thola i-HomePod. Kodwa isikhulumi se-Echo sihloniphekile, futhi ezinye izinsiza zedivayisi zingasiza ukucasula ikhwalithi yomsindo encane.

Ikhaya le-Smart: U-Tie

Isithombe sesikweletu: narvikk / iStock / Getty Images Plus

Esinye sezithembiso ezinkulu zezikhulumi ezihlakaniphile ukuthi zingakwazi ukuhlala phakathi kwendawo yakho ehlakaniphile futhi zikuvumele ukulawula izibani zakho, i-thermostat, namanye amadivaysi axhunyiwe nge-intanethi ngezwi. Ngalokhu ngaphambili, isikhulumi oyifunayo sizoxhomeke kakhulu kulokho okunye amadivaysi ehlakaniphile asekhaya. I-HomePod isekela izinga lasekhaya le- HomeKit le-Apple (eliphinde lisetshenziswe kumadivayisi we-iOS njenge-iPhone). I-Echo ayisekeli i-HomeKit, kodwa isekela ezinye izindinganiso kanye nenani elikhulu lamadivaysi ehlakaniphile asekhaya aneamakhono ahambisana ne-Echo.

Imibiko ethunyelwayo: I-Echo (kodwa nje kancane)

Isikweletu somfanekiso: i-Amazon

Kokubili i-Echo ne-HomePod ingakusiza ukuxhumana ngefoni noma ngomlayezo wombhalo. Ngokuqondile ukuthi benza kanjani lokhu okuhlukile, noma kunjalo. I-HomePod ayenzi izingcingo ngokwayo; kunalokho ungadlulisela ucingo kusuka ku-iPhone yakho ku-HomePod bese uyisebenzisa njengesiprofetho. Ngakolunye uhlangothi, i-Echo ingakwazi ukwenza ucingo oluqondile kusuka kudivayisi-futhi ezinye ze-Echo zisekela ngisho nokushaya ividiyo. Imilayezo yombhalo, kokubili amadivaysi anikeza kakhulu izici ezifanayo, ngaphandle kokuthi i-Echo ayithumeli imilayezo nge- Apple iMessage platform ephephile , okuyi-HomePod eyenzayo.

I-Form Factor nokusetshenziswa eNdlu: Echo

Isikweletu somfanekiso: i-Amazon

I-HomePod iyisidingo esisha ngakho-ke ifika ngesayizi eyodwa kanye nokuma. I-Echo ihluke kakhulu futhi inikeza amamodeli ahlukene kuzo zonke izinhlobo zokusetshenziswa. Kukhona i-Echo noma i-Echo Plus yama-cylindrical, i- Echo Dot e -hockey-puck-size, i- echo -clock-style Echo Spot, i- Echo Show ye -video-calling ephakathi kwe-video ebizwa nge-Echo Look. Konke kuzo zonke, i-Echo ihambisana nokuhlukahluka ngobukhulu bayo, ukuma, nokugxila.

Abasebenzisi abaningi: Echo

Isithombe se-copyright Hero Images / Getty Images

Uma unabantu abangaphezu kweyodwa endlini yakho ofuna ukusebenzisa isikhulumi esihlakaniphile, i-Echo ibheja yakho engcono kakhulu okwamanje. Kungenxa yokuthi i-Echo ingahlukanisa phakathi kwamazwi, ufunde ukuthi bangobani, futhi uphendule ngokuhlukile ngokusekelwe kulokho. I-HomePod ayikwazi ukwenza lokho okwamanje. Lokhu akuyona nje umkhawulo, kungase kube yilezi zinkinga zobumfihlo. Ngenxa yokuthi i-HomePod ayikwazi ukunquma ukuthi izwi lakho lingokwakho, noma ubani angangena endlini yakho, cela uSiri ukuthi afunde imiyalezo yakho, bese uwazwa (uma nje i-iPhone yakho isendlini, okungukuthi). Lindela i-HomePod ukuze uthole ukwesekwa kwabasebenzisi abaningi kanye nezinyathelo zobumfihlo ezingcono ekugcineni, kodwa okwamanje, i-Echo ihamba phambili kulezo zindawo.

I-Apple Ecosystem Integration: I-HomePod

Isikweletu somfanekiso: Apple Inc.

Uma usuvele utshala kakhulu kwi-Apple ecosystem (ie Macs, iPhones, iPads, njll) -IngomaPod iyibheja yakho engcono kakhulu. Kungenxa yokuthi ihlanganiswe ngokuqinile kwi-Apple ecosystem futhi isebenza ngokuzenzekelayo ngalawo madivayisi kanye nezinsizakalo ze-Apple njenge- iCloud . Lokho kwenza ukusetha okulula, ukusebenzisana okungaphezulu, nokusebenza okubushelelezi. I-Echo ingasebenza ngamanani alawa madivaysi, nakuba kungenjalo, futhi ngeke uthole inzuzo yawo yonke imikhiqizo namasevisi we-Apple nge-Echo.